Memorable matches - Charlton Athletic 4-4 Sunderland, Division One play-off Final 1998

By Simon Wright - Follow me on Twitter @Siwri88

The play-off weekend in May 1998 had been a big disappointment upto the staging of the Division One play-off final.  Colchester United had beaten Torquay United 1-0 in the Division Three final, whilst Grimsby Town had overcome Northampton Town by the same scoreline in Division Two.

The Division One final was between Charlton Athletic and Sunderland, and it didn’t promise much.  In the last seven meetings between the sides, there had only been seven goals in total, and both matches in the regular campaign had ended in draws.  The experts predicted it would be a techy, tepid affair but then, what do they know.

Sunderland started the game as favourites having finished third in the league, only missing out on automatic promotion by a single point.  They had overturned a first leg deficit in the semi-finals to beat Sheffield United.  Charlton were on a great defensive run and had stretched their clean sheet sequence to 10 after shutting out Ipswich Town in the other semi, winning 2-0 on aggregate.

The match was going to the formbook in the early stages with few clear openings but the deadlock was eventually broken in the 24th minute.  Former Sheffield Wednesday poacher Mark Bright flicked the ball on with his head to his prolific strike partner Clive Mendonca.  Mendonca produced a brilliant turn on the edge of the penalty area to spin away from his marker Jody Craddock and then beat Lionel Perez in the Sunderland goal with consummate ease.

In the first half, Sunderland looked second best.  However they immediately started pressing higher on the restart and got an instant reward.  The presence of Niall Quinn was crucial, as he was first to Nicky Summerbee’s corner at the near post to power the Wearsiders level five minutes into the restart.

Quinn missed a golden chance shortly afterwards when unmarked in the area from Lee Clark’s long pass, but Kevin Phillips ensured Sunderland’s more free approach was working when he gave them a deserved lead moments later.  Kevin Ball’s strong challenge put Phillips in the clear and he beat Sasa Ilic to a ball the goalkeeper never looked like winning the race to.  The goal made Phillips the top scorer in the country in season 1997-98.

Undeterred from a rocky 15 minute spell, Charlton’s response was impressive.  Substitute Steve Jones played in Mendonca with an incisive ball pass and the in-form attacker tucked home his second of the afternoon in the 71st minute.  To rub salt into the wounds of Sunderland, Mendonca was a boyhood Black Cats fans.

Seconds later, Peter Reid’s side went down the other end of the field in this unbelievable match and regained control.  A tremendous ball from Clark found Quinn, who controlled the cross brilliantly on the chest and then beat Ilic at the near post.

The goalkeepers weren’t having a great day.  Perez was caught in no man’s land with four minutes left of normal time, and Richard Rufus rose highest from John Robinson’s corner to power home his first ever goal for Charlton Athletic.

It was a pulsating match, especially in the second half and the thrills continued into extra time.  For the third time in the game, Sunderland took the lead nine minutes into the first period.  Nicky Summerbee lashed a right foot shot past Ilic after some good build-up work from Quinn, who was a menace for the Charlton backline all afternoon.

Once again though, Charlton’s response was great, drawing level for a third time just before half-time in extra time.  Mendonca completed his hat-trick in grand style. 

And so it went to penalties and they were largely faultless.  In fact, the first 13 spot-kicks were successful.  The 14th penalty was not.  Michael Gray’s weak effort was comfortably saved by Ilic and Charlton were promoted into the Premiership for the first time.  For Sunderland, another season in Division One beckoned although they would go up the following campaign as champions.

The ultimate winner though was football.  Once again, the play-offs had delivered the most ultimate drama possible.

DATE: 25th May 1998
LOCATION: Wembley Stadium
ATTENDANCE: 77,739
REFEREE: Eddie Wolstenholme
FINAL SCORE: Charlton Athletic 4-4 Sunderland (CHARLTON WON 7-6 ON PENALTIES)
GOALSCORERS: Clive Mendonca 23, 71, 103, Niall Quinn 50, 73, Kevin Phillips 58, Richard Rufus 85, Nicky Summerbee 99

TEAMS – Charlton: Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills, Eddie Youds, Richard Rufus, Mark Bowen, Mark Kinsella, Shaun Newton, Keith Jones, Neil Heaney, Mark Bright, Clive Mendonca

SUBS: Steve Jones (for Heaney) 65 minutes, John Robinson (for Mills) 76 minutes, Steve Brown (for Bright) 93 minutes

Sunderland: Lionel Perez, Darren Holloway, Darren Williams, Jody Craddock, Michael Gray, Nicky Summerbee, Kevin Ball, Lee Clark, Allan Johnston, Kevin Phillips, Niall Quinn

SUBS: Chris Makin (for Holloway) 45 minutes, Danny Dichio (for Phillips) 73 minutes, Alex Rae (for Clark) 100 minutes

Comments